Skip to contents
Pilsen, Little Village, West Loop

A $350 PB&J Sandwich? You Can Try It At This New West Loop Restaurant

Pizza, Beer and Jukebox, or PB&J, offers specialty pizzas, burgers and sandwiches and has 26 beers on tap.

PB&J officially opens in the West Loop Tuesday.
Francis Son
  • Credibility:

WEST LOOP — Pizza, Beer and Jukebox, a restaurant serving Neapolitan-style pizza, gourmet burgers, beers and more, has opened its doors in West Loop.

Brothers Matthew and Josh McCahill launched Pizza, Beer and Jukebox, or PB&J, for dinner service Tuesday at 205 N. Peoria St.

The new eatery offers small bites, sandwiches, gourmet burgers and specialty pizzas.

Credit: Kira Anderson)
Burrata and Balsamic pizza

The menu also includes a pricey version of its namesake item, the PB&J sandwich. For $350, diners can indulge in the “Golden Goose,” a sandwich made with edible gold leaf bread, Adams all-natural peanut butter, a drizzle of New Zealand manuka honey and Maison Dutriez’s red currant jam — “the world’s most expensive jelly, which is [deseeded] using goose quills,” according to the menu.

That sandwich must be ordered one day in advance.

The inspiration for the $350 PB&J sandwich came after Matthew McCahill was unimpressed by a $299 PB&J in California, he told Eater.

“All it was, was a gold toothpick … . I thought that was boring,” he told Eater.

Credit: Kira Anderson
Matthew and Josh McCahill open PB&J in West Loop.

The restaurant will also serve up more affordable PB&J versions, including the Wonder Bread PB&J starting at $5 and the Not Your Mama’s PB&J, an oven-toasted multigrain sandwich with almond butter, berry compote and maple-bourbon honey. You also can make your own PB&J for $10.

Drinks include cocktails and 26 beers on tap.

Credit: Kira Anderson
PB&J officially opens in West Loop Tuesday.

PB&J will host theme nights, including Jukebox Gone Country, when there will be barbecue dishes and country music.

“We envision PB&J as more of a pizza bakery with good times, good music and great beer,” Matthew McCahill said in a statement.

PB&J will be open 11 a.m.-2 a.m. daily starting July 14.

Credit: Kira Anderson
Country Chicken Sandwich

Subscribe to Block Club Chicago. Every dime we make funds reporting from Chicago’s neighborhoods.

Already subscribe? Click here to support Block Club with a tax-deductible donation.